Cooperstown Credentials - Committees
"Baseball is like church. Many attend, few understand." – Leo Durocher
The Baseball Hall of Fame not only relies on the Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA) for electing inductees but also on specialized committees to ensure a comprehensive and fair selection process. These committees are designed to review the careers of players, managers, umpires, and executives who may have been overlooked by the BBWAA or who are from earlier periods of baseball history.
Welcome to Ballpark Confidential: Baseball’s Backstory on Culture, Society, & History. Whether you’re a die-hard fan, a newcomer to the game, or just someone who enjoys a good baseball story, we’re set to dive deep into the essence of baseball, uncovering pivotal moments and key figures. This is more than a history lesson; it’s a judgment of how baseball reflects and influences our culture and society.
In this series, "Cooperstown Credentials: A History of Changing Standards," we'll dive into the history and details of what it takes to be inducted into the Hall of Fame.
A new installment of Cooperstown Credentials comes out every Wednesday!
The Veterans Committee was established in 1939, just a few years after the first class of Hall of Fame inductees in 1936. The primary purpose was to recognize players and other significant figures in baseball who were no longer eligible for election by the BBWAA but who deserved recognition for their contributions to the game.
Initially, the Veterans Committee focused on inducting players from the early years of baseball, particularly those who had retired before the BBWAA voting process was firmly established. This included 19th-century players and early 20th-century figures who had made significant impacts on the sport.
As the Hall of Fame grew, it became apparent that different eras of baseball required distinct consideration due to the evolving nature of the game, changes in playing styles, and varying levels of historical documentation and media coverage.
In 2010, the Hall of Fame restructured the Veterans Committee into Era Committees to better address the historical context of candidates. This restructuring aimed to ensure a more organized and era-specific evaluation process. The restructuring divided the history of baseball into distinct eras, each with its own committee responsible for reviewing and voting on candidates.
Early Baseball Era Committee (Prior to 1950)
The Early Baseball Era Committee is a specialized group within the Baseball Hall of Fame responsible for evaluating and selecting candidates whose primary contributions to the game occurred before 1950. This includes players, managers, umpires, and executives from the earliest days of professional baseball up to mid-20th century. The committee was established to ensure that significant figures from baseball's formative years receive appropriate recognition.
The period before 1950 encompasses significant eras such as the pre-professional era, the establishment of the National League in 1876, the American League in 1901, and the integration of the two into Major League Baseball. It also includes the Dead Ball Era (characterized by low-scoring games and a focus on pitching and defense), and the beginnings of the live-ball era, marked by an increase in home runs and offensive play.
The Early Baseball Era Committee meets less frequently than other Era Committees, typically every 10 years. This longer interval reflects the relative stability and fewer changes in the pool of eligible candidates from this historical period.
"People ask me what I do in winter when there’s no baseball. I’ll tell you what I do. I stare out the window and wait for spring." Rogers Hornsby
Golden Days Era Committee (1950-1969)
The Golden Days Era Committee is responsible for evaluating and selecting candidates who made significant contributions to the game of baseball during the post-World War II era through the 1960s. This period was marked by transformative changes, including the integration of baseball, the expansion of the league, and significant developments in how the game was played and perceived.
This period began with baseball's resurgence following World War II. It was a time of renewed enthusiasm for the sport, with many returning veterans contributing to its growth.
The late 1940s and 1950s were marked by the integration of baseball, starting with Jackie Robinson breaking the color barrier in 1947. This era saw the inclusion of many talented African American players who had previously been excluded from Major League Baseball.
The 1960s saw the expansion of Major League Baseball with new teams and the relocation of existing teams to new cities, broadening the sport's geographic reach and fan base.
This era witnessed significant cultural and social changes, reflected in the evolving nature of the sport, its increasing commercialization, and the growing influence of television. The Golden Days Era Committee meets every five years.
Modern Baseball Era Committee (1970-1987)
The Modern Baseball Era Committee is tasked with evaluating and selecting candidates who made significant contributions to the game of baseball during the 1970s and 1980s. This period was marked by major changes, including increased commercialization, rising player salaries, and the advent of free agency. The committee ensures that players, managers, umpires, and executives from this dynamic era receive proper recognition.
The 1970s and 1980s saw baseball become more commercialized, with greater emphasis on media rights, sponsorships, and marketing. Television broadcasts expanded the sport’s reach and influence.
This era witnessed a dramatic increase in player salaries due to the advent of free agency, which allowed players to negotiate contracts with teams more freely after fulfilling certain conditions.
The period was characterized by a more level playing field, with different teams achieving success and competitive playoff races becoming the norm.
The 1970s and 1980s were also a time of cultural shifts within the sport, reflecting broader societal changes. The Modern Baseball Era Committee meets every five years.
Today’s Game Era Committee (1988-Present)
The Today’s Game Era Committee is responsible for evaluating and selecting candidates who have made significant contributions to baseball from 1988 onward. This period encompasses the most recent decades of baseball history, marked by major advancements and changes in the sport, including the use of advanced statistics, globalization, and the influence of modern media.
This era saw the rise of Sabermetrics and advanced statistics, which have transformed how players' performances are evaluated and how teams are managed.
Baseball has become a more international sport, with players from all over the world making significant impacts in Major League Baseball (MLB). This includes increased participation from countries like Japan, Korea, the Dominican Republic, and Venezuela.
The growth of cable television, internet streaming, and social media has changed how fans consume baseball. These platforms have increased the sport’s visibility and allowed fans to engage with the game in new ways.
This period also includes significant changes in labor relations, with notable strikes and lockouts, as well as the escalation of player salaries and revenue from broadcasting rights. The Today’s Game Era Committee meets every five years.
Selection and Voting Process
Each committee reviews a list of potential candidates who meet the era-specific criteria. These lists are curated by historians, Hall of Fame members, and other knowledgeable baseball experts.
Committee members conduct an in-depth review of each candidate's career and contributions, considering statistics, achievements, and impact on the game, as well as character and sportsmanship.
Committee members vote on candidates, typically requiring a candidate to receive at least 75% of the votes to be inducted. This high threshold ensures that only those with broad and significant support are selected.
The Era Committees provide a more nuanced approach to evaluating candidates by considering the specific historical contexts in which they played, managed, or contributed to the game. This approach helps address potential biases and ensures a fair evaluation across different periods in baseball history.
The establishment and evolution of the Veterans Committee into Era Committees reflect the Baseball Hall of Fame's commitment to a fair and comprehensive selection process. By dividing the history of baseball into distinct eras and ensuring that candidates from all periods receive proper consideration, the Hall of Fame honors the rich and varied legacy of the sport, recognizing those who have made significant contributions across different times in its history.
Players Elected to the Hall of Fame via Era Committees (by Year)
Below is a list of players elected to the Hall of Fame via the various Era Committees (including Veterans Committee, Early Baseball Era Committee, Golden Days Era Committee, Modern Baseball Era Committee, and Today’s Game Era Committee) by the year of their election:
Veterans Committee (Up to 2010)
1945: Roger Bresnahan, Fred Clarke, Jimmy Collins, Ed Delahanty, Hugh Duffy, Hughie Jennings, King Kelly, Jim O'Rourke, Wilbert Robinson
1946: Jesse Burkett, Frank Chance, Jack Chesbro, Johnny Evers, Clark Griffith, Tommy McCarthy, Joe McGinnity, Eddie Plank, Joe Tinker, Rube Waddell
1949: Mordecai Brown, Kid Nichols, Charlie Comiskey
1953: Dizzy Dean, Al Simmons
1954: Bill Terry, Bill Dickey
1955: Joe DiMaggio
1964: Luke Appling, Red Ruffing
1967: Lloyd Waner
1968: Joe Medwick
1971: Satchel Paige
1980: Duke Snider
1982: Hank Aaron, Frank Robinson
1991: Rod Carew, Fergie Jenkins, Gaylord Perry
2001: Bill Mazeroski
2003: Gary Carter, Eddie Murray
2009: Joe Gordon
Early Baseball Era Committee (Prior to 1950)
2016: Wes Ferrell, Bill Dahlen, Harry Stovey
2021: Buck O’Neil, Bud Fowler
Golden Days Era Committee (1950-1969)
2012: Ron Santo
2021: Minnie Miñoso, Gil Hodges, Jim Kaat, Tony Oliva
Modern Baseball Era Committee (1970-1987)
2018: Jack Morris, Alan Trammell
2019: Marvin Miller (executive), Ted Simmons
2022: Jim Kaat, Tony Oliva
Today’s Game Era Committee (1988-Present)
2019: Lee Smith, Harold Baines
2022: Fred McGriff